Old-school segregation in Omaha
So, I just got word today that a school district in Omaha, Nebraska is basically re-segregating their system into three districts that are predominately white, black and Hispanic. There are four possible scenarios for the district lines, but in every one two of the districts are predominately minority. The supporters of the plan say that it gives minorities control over their own school boards and ensures that their kids aren’t shortchanged in favor of white students. The opponents of the plan say that it sets race relations back and may be un-Constitutional. In response to that, Senator Ernie Chambers, a black senator who supports the new setup, pointed out that the districts are already segregated because it stopped busing students out of their way for the sake of integration. The system already has a neighborhood schools plan in place, which many people oppose because most of America lives in segregated neighborhoods.
I don’t have a problem with this, because you wouldn’t catch me living in Omaha anyway and I don’t have kids. For me, the ideal school system is one where you can choose your school and opt to be bused out to magnet schools with special interest programs. I came up in a system like that and I'm kick ass! (sorry that just came out). What I meant to say was that I chose an all-black high school with a magnet program; it just happened to be the best high school in the state with the proudest alumni. It was the smartest move I ever made and to this day, I’m impressed with my insight. But enough about dear Dudley High. We were in need of things the district would never dream of having our white counterparts attend school without, but we still had pride. Oh, did I say enough about that?
This move in Omaha seems to be a creative solution to a problem that’s been haunting schools since people who weren’t white were allowed to learn. In Omaha, they claim that students with large non-white student populations aren’t getting the resources and quality of teachers that schools with mostly white students get. Therefore, it makes sense that if your district school board were made up of parents of the same race, you’d erase the inequality that exists. If, of course, that inequality is the result of racism. It sounds like they’re pretty sure it is, which is another issue.
This is a major set back in race relations, no doubt. While busing kinda sucks, I think we’ve seen the results of years of forced integration. Younger generations are more accepting of each other’s differences. It’s to the point where being gay is one of the biggest issues in schools these days, not being a minority. Kimora Lee Simmons just donating a lot of funding for a school that’s primarily for gay students. Yet, another form of segregation, of course, it’s all about acceptance. Neighborhood schools don’t foster acceptance and also bring socio-economic differences to the forefront. While rich kids will always standout with their fancy cars, new sneakers and high-end clothing, it will also stand out when a whole school of those kids come to your raggedy football field for a game. When their basketball team has hot, new warm-ups and you’re team is wearing that same bullshit from the 80s.
Where was I, segregation is still bad but can be good. Students should also have the choice to choose because all people aren't comfortable in homogenous all-white or all-Hispanic settings. Some people need diversity in their lives and imagine this, actually enjoy it! If schools aren’t going to be fully integrated, then these kids have to meet on a common ground somewhere. College is way too late.
[The picture above is of a Charlotte, NC student going to an "integrated" school for the first time. ]
3 Comments:
OK I don't have a lot of time but I'll be back make a propper post. I just have to say this real quick..
I have to disagree with you on this one, my crusty friend. It do not think segregation is good for the students in Omaha or any and other part of the U.S.
AND I can't believe their school board got together and agreed that the only way they can keep racism from being an issue in their decision making process is to have each race go and do their own thing...
(more on this tomorrow while I'm at work not working)
this is just going to cause more problems on the college-level. when these kids get around people of other races for the first time, and start asking stupid-ass questions like "can i touch your hair?". this is going to set their interpersonal development back by light years, so that they all seem like the mother on Black.White.
oh... i heard that they might be closing Carver and Dudley (i think because of accredidation). Know any of the details surrounding that?
I will be looking into the closing of Dudley, and yes I've heard these rumors. They don't surprise me because the school is completely remodeled and looks too good. I believe that even if they close "Dudley" the brand new campus will be used by a new school and new students. They went the most expensive route to renovating the school rather than tearing it down, so I know that money isn't going to go to waste.
The students at Dudley and another high school with a strong minority population, Smith, have to produce more passing End of Grade test scores for the schools to accept students in the fall. If they fail in large numbers the schools will be closed.
It's funny because this is like the situation in that movie Lean on Me. Before I went to Dudley it reminded me of Eastside high from that Morgan Freeman movie- there were gangs and violence and a big movement to clean it up and bus trouble-makers out. It was working and even in my four years I went from watching three -four fights a day as a freshman to coordinating press conferences about the media's negative portrayal of our school by senior year. What triggered the press conference? Our principal was arrested for allowing us to ignore fire alarms because they were being pulled so often that we were losing learning time. How Eastside High is that?!
The school improved but our reputation was still in the gutter. The violence stopped to the point that "bad kids" felt it was boring at Dudley and started going, guess where? Smith.
Now both of these schools are in danger of closing and the education is still suffering from the perception that teachers have of the students who attend these schools. It's not about integration, it's about the fact that many teachers don't want to teach in minority environments, unless they are of color. So, if you won't teach a classroom full of black kids, how will you treat those same kids in your integrated class room?
Segregation is bad, but there are pros to optional all-minority environments, similar to our college system. (You can choose an HBCU or any level of integration in between.) This builds a sense of self-worth and pride that isn't encouraged in mixed environments where White is not only right but smart (and better qualified for student government, and better built for cheerleading and the list goes on...)
This strong sense of pride is EXACTLY what black people need to survive in America. You can't kick down doors if you believe you belong outside.
I think high school should be more like college and that all-minority schools should be available. A child from an homogenous neighborhood, could learn alot from an integrated environment, so nothing should be forced- options should be out there.
Post a Comment
Subscribe to Post Comments [Atom]
<< Home